Heavy punishment?
Saw this at a playground:
The forbidden acts are:
(1) Vandalising plants
(2) Bringing dog
(3) Act of indecency
(4) Sunning laundry
(5) Vandalising public facilities
(6) Hawking
(7) Littering
(8) Cycling / Motorbiking
Ok, these sounds sensible except that personally I think (2) is not needed (this will need a separate post to explain, which I'm not going to do anyway). However, look at the possible punishment:
A fine not exceeding RM 2000 or jail for not more than 1 year or both. So the maximum possible punishment is RM 2000 plus 1 year of jail time.
Alright, which do you think is the most dangerous act among the 8 acts listed above? For me, it's motorbiking in the playground. Whatever you choose, do you think it deserves the maximum punishment? Even discounting the fine, does it deserve 1 year of jail time?
RM 2000 + 1 year in jail is disproportionately heavy for, say, merely motorbiking in a playground and not on the consequence of it. If the biker hit someone, surely there is a law that deals with that specifically?
So why such hefty punishment?
The forbidden acts are:
(1) Vandalising plants
(2) Bringing dog
(3) Act of indecency
(4) Sunning laundry
(5) Vandalising public facilities
(6) Hawking
(7) Littering
(8) Cycling / Motorbiking
Ok, these sounds sensible except that personally I think (2) is not needed (this will need a separate post to explain, which I'm not going to do anyway). However, look at the possible punishment:
A fine not exceeding RM 2000 or jail for not more than 1 year or both. So the maximum possible punishment is RM 2000 plus 1 year of jail time.
Alright, which do you think is the most dangerous act among the 8 acts listed above? For me, it's motorbiking in the playground. Whatever you choose, do you think it deserves the maximum punishment? Even discounting the fine, does it deserve 1 year of jail time?
RM 2000 + 1 year in jail is disproportionately heavy for, say, merely motorbiking in a playground and not on the consequence of it. If the biker hit someone, surely there is a law that deals with that specifically?
So why such hefty punishment?
Comments
I know that lah and that's not the point. The point is why such heavy maximum punishment when no act (among the list) deserves it?